Indian Res. J. Genet. & Biotech. 5(3) : 160-164 (2013)Antibiotic sensitivity profile of the test isolates of E. coli isolated from clinical cases of diarrhea in the kids of goat breeds S. K. Rajput1, K. Gururaj2, D.V. Singh3 and Gitam Singh4
1, 2, 4 C. I. R. G, Makhdoom, Farah, Mathura, U.P., 3K.V.K., Nabarangpur, Odisha.
(Received : May, 2013 : Revised : June, 2013; Accepted : July, 2013)
Abstract The samples were taken using sterile cotton swab tubes, and were labeled and kept in the refrigerator at 4°C until further processing. These samples were collected from less than one month old Jamunapari, Barbari, Jakharana, Sirohi kids during the period from March to June 2010. Some of the commonly used antibiotics like Ampicillin, and Cloxacillin were giving high percentage of resistance at the rate of 75 percent and 100% respectively. This is due to the unscrupulous use of such antibiotics leading to high resistance. About 67 percent of the isolates were resistant to Oxytetracycline, Gentamicin, and Ceftriaxone. Only antibiotic groups like fluoroquinolones and the Chloramphenicol have fared well in effectively inhibiting the in vitro growth of E. coli. Chloramphenicol has given the lowest percentage of resistance at zero and the next best was Enrofloxacin at 34 percent. So, it’s a serious issue that out of the commonly used 7 antibiotics, only two was effective, which gives clue about the emerging multi-drug resistant E. coli strains. Key words: antibiotic sensitivity, E. coli, kids, goat
infectious organism by looking at the color,
consistency, or odor of the feces. A definitive
identification requires a sample for microbiological
Introduction
analysis. In livestock, diarrhea is called scours.
Goat population in the world was 464,323000 in
There are many causes of diarrhea: bacterial, viral,
1980; 591,367000 in 1990; 746,689000 in 2000;
parasites, and diet (Joe Rook 2007). Diarrhoeal
diseases are the top listed disease causing death
6,674,801000 human populations in 2008. Goat
of kids. Colibacillosis and septicemia are generally
population in India was 86,900000 in 1980;
taken as the most common cause of mortality in
juvenile kids in India (Vihan et al, 1990) along with
125,732000 in 2008; 39 goat breeds; 1,139,965000
other infectious organism like Cryptosporidium
human population in 2008; 1,080 US$ gross national
parvum, rota virus, Clostridium perfringens and
income per capita (Shrestha et al., 2011). Salmonella species. Morbidity rate (60.8%) and
Diarrhea is defined as an increased frequency,
Colibacillosis in kids in organized farm (Kumar et
fluidity, or volume of fecal excretion. The feces may
al, 2001). Outbreak of colibacillosis in established
contain blood or mucous and may have foetid odour.
The color of the feces may be abnormal. However,
it is not possible to definitively determine the
Correspondance author's e-mail : [email protected], [email protected] by Indian Society of Genetics, Biotechnology Research and Development, 114, IInd floor Biotech Bhawan, PuspanjaliCommercial Complex, Shastripuram Road, Sikandra 282007
Antibiotic sensitivity profile of the test isolates of E. coli .
Diarrhoea caused by Escherichia coli infection is
and sub cultured for further characterization. To
responsible for high rates of mortality in goat kids
check whether the bacteria are E. coli (because
which causes important economical loss in goat-
there are other lactose fermenters like Klebsiella
rearing. Goat kids are especially susceptible to E.
and Enterobacter) the LF+ colonies were re-
coli scours during the first week of life. A constant
inoculated on EMB agar for presence of metallic
bacteriological finding in enteric colibacillosis is the
sheen, which was given only by E. coli. The
intense proliferation of certain serotypes of E. coli
organism was identified on the basis of culture,
in the small intestine whiles the number of other
morphological and biochemical characteristics
bacteria in the gut remains normal (Hodgson, 1994).
(Karter, 1973). On the basis of microscopic
Diseases are the major cause of economic losses
examination, morphology of bacteria was noted as
and inefficient production of livestock and main
rod, spiral or filament. It was differentiated by Bio-
constraint in development of livestock particularly of
chemical characterization as per Jackie Reynolds
goat industry in country. The risk of endemic
diseases contributes significantly, which is
Initially the Glass wares and other media are
considered more obvious under Indian conditions.
sterilized and kept ready. MHA was sterilized by
Materials and Methods
autoclaving at the rate 121ºC in 15 lbs for 15minutes
and poured in to Petri plates and checked for
E. coli was isolated from faeces of Kids suffering
sterility. Bacterial Inoculums was prepared from
from clinical diarrhoea. The Jamunapari, Barbari,
each isolates in normal saline and matched with
Jakhrana, Sirohi goat unit of CIRG Makhdoom,
McFarland Standards as mentioned by Kirby &
farah, Mathura was selected for collection of
Bauer (1966). A lawn culture was prepared using the
primary inoculums by spreading the inoculums on
diarrhoea were selected and screened out. The
to the Agar surface nicely by using a sterile glass
samples were taken using sterile cotton swab
spreader (sterilized by 70% alcohol). After 15
tubes, and were labeled and kept in the refrigerator
minutes, the antibiotics discs were applied on to the
at 4°C until further processing. These samples were
agar surface by the applicator/ sterile forceps with
collected from less than one month old Jamunapari,
optimum distance between each antibiotic disc. The
Barbari, Jakharana, Sirohi kids during the period
Petri plates embedded with antibiotic discs are
incubated at 37ºC for 24 hours. After incubation the
Isolation of E. coli
results are read by measuring the zone of inhibition
The fecal swabs collected were directly inoculated
using a calibrated scale. The results are interpreted
for each antibiotic by measuring the zone of
simultaneously in duplicates for every sample
inhibition and comparing the standard chart for the
inoculums. Then the plates are incubated at 37ºC
for 24 to 48 hours. After growth was observed the
Results and Discussion
similar colonies were stained by the “grams” for
Isolates were further assessed for the antibacterial
examining the size, morphology and staining
drug susceptibility by using disc diffusion method.
characteristics. The colony types, which were
Out of 8 antibiotics, the isolates were found to be
showing gram negative cocco bacilli, were further
Oxytetracycline, Gentamicin, Ceftriazone, Cloxocillin
On MacConkey’s agar only lactose fermenting (LF
with inhibition zone diameter ranging between 10-
+) colonies, which were pink in colour were isolated
15 mm. Chloramphenicol were highly sensitive for
Evaluation of Moringa oleifera Seed Extracts for Antibacterial E. coli strains to producing the inhibition zone of 23-
Ceftriazone, and Cloxocillin resulted found to be
26 mm and Ampicillin, Oxytetracycline, Gentamicin,
intermediate the inhibition zone of 13-16 mm each. Table 1: Antibiotic Sensitivity profiles of the field isolates of E. coli. Chloram- S.No Ampicillin Enrofloxacin OTC Gen tamicin Ceftriazone Cloxacillin phenicol
R =Resistant, I= Intermediate, S = Sensitive
Antibiotic sensitivity profile of the test isolates of E. coli .Table 2: Effect of Antibiotics on different isolates of E. coli Antibiotic Resistant Intermediate Sensitive
R =Resistant, I= Intermediate, S = Sensitive
Table 3: Percentage of Resistance of the total isolates shown to different antibiotics Antibiotic Percentage
Antibiotic sensitivity test were done to study the
inhibiting the in vitro growth of E. coli.
trend in susceptibility to commonly used antibiotics
Chloramphenicol has given the lowest percentage
in the field. Only those screened using bfpA gene
of resistance at zero and the next best was
were subjected to antibiotic sensitivity test. Some
Enrofloxacin at 34 percent. So, it’s a serious issue
of the commonly used antibiotics like Ampicillin,
that out of the commonly used 7 antibiotics, only
and Cloxacillin were giving high percentage of
two was effective, which gives clue about the
resistance at the rate of 75 percent and 100%
emerging multi-drug resistant E. coli strains.
respectively. This is due to the unscrupulous use
Gupta et al (2000) subjected drug sensitive test for
of such antibiotics leading to high resistance. About
isolates of faecal sample of effective kids, with the
67 percent of the isolates were resistant to
range of modern antibiotics and samples were
Oxytetracycline, Gentamicin, and Ceftriaxone. Only
sensitive to Amikacin, Cefotaxime, Ceftazidime,
antibiotic groups like fluoroquinolones and the
Ceftrioxone, Cefuroxime, Cefadroxyl, Kanamycin
Chloramphenicol have fared well in effectively
Evaluation of Moringa oleifera Seed Extracts for Antibacterial Jose et al, (2001) isolated quinolone resistance
pathogenic and non-pathogenic Escherichia coli
rearing. Intas Polivet,1: 178-179.
strains from healthy ruminants. In cattle, 5.9% of the
Hodgson J.C. (1994). Diseases due to
strains were resistant to nalidixic acid and 4.9%
Escherichia coli in shepp. In: C.L. Gyles (Ed.).
were resistant to enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin,
Escherichiu coli in domestic animals and
whereas in sheep and goats only 0.5% and 1.4%,
humans. CAB International. UK, pp. 135- 150.
respectively, of the strains were resistant to nalidixic
acid and none to fluoroquinolones. Most of the
Joe Rook (2007), Diarrhea (scours) in small
strains resistant to quinolones were non-pathogenic
ruminant, Last updated by Susan Schoenian
strains isolated from cattle. But in the current study
the resistance to fluoroquinolones was as high as
Jose A. Orden, Jos A., Ruiz-Santa-
34 percent, making it a concern, for the future use
Quiteria, Dolores Cid, Rosa Díez, Susana Martínez and Ricardo de la Fuente (2001)
Kumar et al, (2003) isolated nineteen different
Quinolone resistance in potentially pathogenic
serotype of E. coli from faecal sample of diarrheic
and non-pathogenic Escherichia coli strains
cow and calves. Multiple drug resistance was a
isolated from healthy ruminants. Journal of
common feature belonging to isolates from all
Antimicrobial Chemotherapy,48: 421-424.
categories of animals. Highest resistance was
Kumar A., Vaid R.K., Rana R., Vihan VS
against ampicillin and oxytetracycline. and Gupta VK (2001) Descriptive epidemiology Conclusion
of colibacillosis outbreak in Barbari kids under
semi-intensive system, Indian J. of Animal
Biochemical studies like IMViC, TSI, Oxidase,
Sciences, 72; 233-236.
Catalase and Nitrate tests identified different strains
of E. coli from clinical cases of diarrhea. Only
Kumar Monoj and Richa (2003) Prevalence
Chloramphenicol showed good percentage of
and Antibiogram of E. coli serotypes in healthy
affectiveness against the pathogenic E. coli
and diarrhoeic Cattle in Jabalpur (MP), Indian
isolates, Ampicillin, Enrofloxacin, Oxytetracycline,
Vet. Med. Jour., 27: 235-237.
Gentamycin, Ceftrioxone, and Cloxacillin antibiotics
Shrestha J.N.B. and Galal E.S.E. (2011).
showed alarmingly low level of effectiveness in
Conservation of goat genetic resources. Small
inhibiting the growth of pathogenic E. coli in vitro. Ruminant Research, (in press). References Vihan V.S., singh S.V. and Sing N. (1990)
Prevalence, pathogenecity and serotypes of E.Gupta V.K., Kumar A. and Singh N. (2000) coli associated with diarrhoea in newborn kids,
Indian J. Animals Science,60, 793-795.
Bacteremia associated with naturally occurring acute coliform mastitis in dairy cows John R. Wenz, DVM, MS; George M. Barrington, DVM, PhD, DACVIM; Franklyn B. Garry, DVM, MS, DACVIM;Kevin D. McSweeney, BS; R. Page Dinsmore, DVM, DABVP; Gregory Goodell, DVM; become the predominant form of mastitis in herds inwhich contagious mastitis has been effectively con- Objective —To determine the